That's from the headline the NYT gives to a story on Yale University's chapel severing ties with the United Church of Christ. "In quest to be more welcoming, Yale is severing ties to a church." Ouch.
Evidently, attendance, especially among students, has been in sharp decline at the UCC congregation that worships at the Yale chapel. From what I can glean of the "official-speak" of various press releases, it seems that the Yale administrators feel that the UCC affiliation is not "welcoming" enough to attract students.
Now, we can deconstruct the meaning of "welcoming" all day... I'm pretty sure that by the standards of a North American university, Jesus would in no way be labelled "welcoming." "Welcoming," in this atmosphere, means something very different than it would in a biblical context. But what interests me in this is that it's the UCC that is being snubbed. The UCC. That's the church body that recently extended a welcome to SpongeBob Squarepants, fer cryin' out loud. A denomination that has welcome and inclusion as a central tenet of its identity. It is a church body that undeniably presents itself as a reasonable, liberal, tolerant, sophisticated alternative to "conservative" Christianity (however one defines that). And it gets jilted by an Ivy League university. That's gotta hurt.
We can pursue relevance on the world's terms ("liberal" or "conservative," "high brow" or "pop") all day long. But the spirit of the age is a fickle mistress. Not only have the UCC's numbers declined (as are the numbers of most, if not all, mainline denominations in North America), but even the bastions of liberal tolerance are not satisfied. (And the same is true on the opposite end of the political - social spectrum as well.) One of the things that gives me hope for the future is seeing in the "emerging church conversations" Christians who seek to establish public identities not crafted from GOP or DNC platforms or lifted from Gap ads and Starbucks promotional materials, but in a seeking, struggling, experimental way, on the character, compassion, and truth of Jesus.